Methods & Data Collection (Edexcel IGCSE Geography)
Primary & Secondary Data
Spec point —
4GE1-S3.045
-
Data collected by the student within their fieldwork is primary data
-
Examples of primary data can include:
- questionnaire data
- river data - width, depth etc.
- video/audio recordings
- photographs
- interview information
-
Data collected by someone else but used by the student in their enquiry is secondary data
-
Examples of secondary data can include:
- census results
- weather data
- old photographs
- maps
- newspaper articles
- websites
Primary data strengths and limitations
| Strengths | - Know that the data is reliable and valid - The data is specific to the enquiry - As much data as needed can be collected - The method of the collection is known - It is up-to-date |
|---|---|
| Limitations | - Time-consuming - May need specialist equipment/resources - The sample size needs to be large to be accurate |
Secondary data strengths and limitations
| Strengths | - Easy to access - Low-cost or free - Can be accessed quickly - A large amount of data sources are available |
|---|---|
| Limitations | - It is not specific to the enquiry - No control over the data quality - Data may be biased - Data may be out of date |
Quantitative & Qualitative Data
Spec point —
4GE1-S3.045
-
Data which records quantities is quantitative data
-
Examples of quantitative data are:
- numerical data collected in questionnaires
- traffic counts
- environmental quality surveys
- river data - velocity, discharge
- weather data
-
Data which records descriptive information is qualitative data
-
Examples of qualitative data:
- field sketches and photographs
- non-numeric questionnaire data
- interview answers
Questionnaires and Interviews
-
When collecting data via questionnaires or interviews several questioning types can be used:
- Closed questions where answers are limited to single words, numbers or a list of options
- Statements which use a scale to gauge people's views. For example, strongly agree/agree
- Open questions where the respondent can give any answer
-
Questionnaires can be used to gather a large sample of data
-
Interviews are more in-depth and tend to be used to gather a smaller data sample
Environmental quality surveys
-
These are used to collect data about the environmental quality of different sites
-
They use the judgement of the person surveying to assess environmental quality against a range of indicators
- Using a sliding scale (1 -5) or bipolar scale (-3 to 3)
- Usually the lower the score the more negative the assessment of the environmental quality
-
They are subjective because they are based on the opinion of the person completing them
-
This can be reduced by:
- Completing in small groups to reach a consensus regarding the score
- Using the mode of EQS completed by several students
-
They produce quantitative data
Quantitative data strengths and limitations
| Strengths | - Possible to have a larger sample size - Information can often be collected quickly - Data collection can be duplicated - More objective than qualitative data - More reliable than qualitative data |
|---|---|
| Limitations | - The meaning behind the results is not clear - Human error or equipment error can lead to mistakes in measurement |
Qualitative data strengths and limitations
| Strengths | - More in-depth than quantitative data - More valid than quantitative data |
|---|---|
| Limitations | - Often a small sample size - Enquiries are not easy to duplicate - Difficult to make comparisons - Low reliability - Time-consuming |
Was this revision note helpful?